0028. Source evidence and playable media are separate assets
- Date: 2026-09-06
- Status: accepted; keeping every acquired master superseded by 0048
- Supersedes: a single mezzanine that replaced the acquired bytes
Context
Transcode kept one H.264/AAC mezzanine and deleted the bytes it came from, and Archive acquisition picked the smallest derivative. That is fine for playback and the wrong foundation for finding where a commercial ends, reading small print, telling an upload defect from the source, or reproducing a model’s judgement later.
Decision
Every clip that reaches transcode has three roles: an immutable source master (the exact acquired bytes, identified by full SHA-256), a reproducible evidence derivative for inspection and models, and a playback derivative for playout. Both derivatives are built from the master under versioned recipes, and a manifest in the sidecar binds them. Archive acquisition picks the best source representation, not the cheapest file.
Consequences
- Reprocessing and recovery never depend on a lossy rendition.
- Storage grows; masters are not garbage-collected until an ownership graph can prove one disposable.
- Split children bind the parent’s media-asset digest and source role, so a later playback-recipe change cannot change what a split meant.
Amendment (2026-10-27, #2036)
An admitted ad keeps its master and its playback copy; its evidence copy is dropped. Every reader of evidence runs before admission, so after it the evidence copy is only storage. A rewind that needs it again starts at the transcode, which rebuilds it from the master under the same recipe. A master is deleted only with the one clip that names it, when that clip is merged into a better copy of its ad or retired for failing the defect floor.